My Harshest Critic

If you saw my guest post on Carla’s blog on Friday (squee!), you know that I have spent some time thinking about judgment. I started off thinking about how I judge others (and trying not to) but ended up realizing how much I judge myself. I really am my own harshest critic. 

Our Harshest Critic (1)
I know I’m not alone, but recent campaigns by Dove have made me realize how pervasive this issue is.

The first one I saw–One Beautiful Thought–is from Canada. 

Don’t be scared off by the subtitltes–it’s worth it! 

I thought this was powerful, but I didn’t take it too personally because I have gotten much better at catching myself when I am engaging in negative self-talk.

But this one–Choose Beautiful–really speaks to me.

I think I would chose “average”, but why?

I think I would choose “average” as a safe choice that shields me from being judged by others. (“She thinks she’s beautiful?!”)

I think I would choose “average” because “beautiful” is an adjective I am comfortable bestowing on others, but not myself. (Sort of the reverse of One Beautiful Thought.)

I think I would choose “average” because choosing “beautiful” seems conceited, but then I think that reaction probably has to do with the ingrained sexism and misogyny of our society. 

But, I think if I were with friends I would lead us all through “beautiful”.

But why?

Would I feel more empowered?

Would I be free-loading off the beauty I see in my friends?

Would I better understand that we are beautiful?

[Tweet “Why are we our harshest critics? #ChooseBeautiful”]

Which door would you walk through?

This entry was posted in Life and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to My Harshest Critic

  1. I’ve been loving this video for the past few weeks it’s such a great message. WE are all our harshest critics aren’t we?

  2. Aimee says:

    I wrote on this topic too last week. What strikes me is the mom pulling her daughter through the beautiful door, and of course I would too, but would I have walked through if she wasn’t with me. I need to stop criticizing myself to empower her to love herself!

  3. I would walk through the average one as well. It sucks that there is such a negative connontation for people to individually call themselves beautiful. People think you are bragging or cocky. I loved that video.

  4. I love this video – hadn’t seen this campaign. I know I would most likely walk through the average door as well, but like you I think if I were with a group of friends I’d push us all through the beautiful door – safety in numbers perhaps?

  5. Kim says:

    I would choose average too because that is the way I’ve always seen myself and I’m OK with that but, like you, I see beauty in everyone around me.
    This really is a great campaign!

  6. Farrah says:

    I’m definitely my harshest critic too, but I’m really working on trying to fix that!

  7. I’d walk through average. Even though I don’t really feel average, but beautiful? Maybe if there was a strong or fit option…lol. I think we just don’t like to build ourselves up like that.

  8. I would walk through average. I guess that is just the way I see myself. Not bad, just normal. Not amazing or beautiful though. We are our harshest critics.

  9. Carrie Skoll says:

    Thank you for sharing this. I kept seeing the video and meaning to watch. I too would definitely pull my friends through the ‘beautiful’ door. And I like to think that I would go through the beautiful door myself if alone. But, I’d definitely hear those voices in my head questioning it. Or at least I would if I had seen the doors in person without having seen this video.

Comments are closed.